I received a copy of this letter by email and thought others might like reading it.
Fear Wins, The Public Loses,
Chamber Public Issues “Forum” Limited to Issue Proponents
written by Kevin Johnson–4-17-06
This morning’s Portsmouth Daily Times front-page article, entitled “Issues forum set for Tuesday,” left me angered and bewildered. Has Portsmouth so become fearful of a small group of people who shout to be heard and denigrate others in their public “participation,” or of certain politicians who seem totally unaware and unconcerned about public opinion, that we now toss away, as inconvenient, one of the basic rights of Americans?
This issues “forum,” hosted by the Chamber of Commerce, is restricted to allowing only the proponents of various City ballot issues to speak. No other points of view are to be allowed. Only written (and obviously screened) questions will be allowed from the audience.
The Chamber has selected Police Chief Charles Horner to talk about a proposed Charter amendment to increase the City’s income tax by 2/10 of one percent to pay for his Drug/Major Crime Investigative Task Force, Council President Howard Baughman to discuss the two recall amendments, and Mayor Jim Kalb to discuss the referendum for repeal of the Marting’s building ordinance.
This is a charade. Each of these individuals is a recognized proponent of their particular issue. And, according to Chamber Administrator Lisa Carver, “There will be no one giving an opposing viewpoint of the issues…” Though Chamber President Bob Huff states “It is not our intention to take a position on any of the upcoming issues,” they definitely have – simply by their design of this so-called public “forum.” If it quacks, it’s a duck.
That the Chamber of Commerce and the Portsmouth Daily Times would call this meeting a “forum” is insulting. The definition of a forum, in this context, is: “a public meeting or assembly for open discussion; a meeting or part of meeting set aside for an open discussion by recognized participants on subjects of public interests.”
In 1943, after toiling night and day at his easel for seven months and losing 15 pounds, the Saturday Evening Post published his monumental Four Freedoms series. The inspirational paintings were based on postwar principles for universal rights as declared by President Roosevelt in a January 6, 1941, message to Congress:
1. Freedom of Speech
2. Freedom of Worship
3. Freedom from Want
4. Freedom from Fear
Public reaction to the Four Freedoms was overwhelming. Rockwell’s paintings touched internal chords important to free people everywhere. The government reproduced the works as posters that reinvigorated populace aid in the war effort. The Treasury Department toured the four originals to sixteen cities. Almost a million and a quarter war-strapped people appreciated them in person. The $130,000,000+ of bonds raised subsequent to the Four Freedoms was instrumental in shortening WWII.
Here in Portsmouth, however, it seems that there are those who are working hard to eliminate, for all citizens of Portsmouth, our freedom of speech and freedom from fear. Perhaps we should alter Norman Rockwell’s painting to show the gentleman with tape over his mouth. In fact, that is exactly how I will be attending this “forum”: with tape over my mouth.
“Forum/Town Meeting” – Tuesday, April 18, 2006
7-9 p.m., Scioto County Welcome Center – 342 Second Street
posted by tkm